Why Liverpool Are Struggling Despite Spending Over £400 Million

 Why Liverpool Are Struggling Despite Spending Over £400 Million

Arne slot

Liverpool entered the 2025–26 season with the expectation that heavy investment would return the club to the top of English football. More than £400 million was spent on key signings across midfield, attack and defence, signalling a clear intent to rebuild and immediately compete at the highest level. Yet, despite this financial outlay, the performances on the pitch have been inconsistent, disjointed and far below the standards Liverpool supporters expect.

The question now dominates football discussions: how can a team strengthened by such significant spending still look so vulnerable?

A Squad Rebuilt but Not Yet a Team

Liverpool’s recent transfer windows have focused on refreshing the squad after the Klopp era, but rebuilding an entire team structure never happens overnight. While the club has added talented individuals, the collective understanding between them has not yet developed. Football at the highest level depends on automatic movements, synchronised pressing triggers, and cohesive positional play. When many players are new, those automatisms simply aren’t there.

Big-money signings often arrive with pressure to perform instantly, but adaptation to a new league, new teammates and new tactical instructions takes time. The Premier League’s pace and physicality make the adjustment period even longer. Liverpool’s new arrivals are gifted, but the lack of immediate chemistry has revealed gaps that opponents have exploited.

Injuries Disrupting Stability

One of the biggest, yet least glamorous, contributors to Liverpool’s struggles has been injuries. Several key players in defence, midfield and attack have missed important periods through fitness issues. This has forced the manager into constant rotation, preventing any consistent back-line or midfield partnership from settling.

Defensive partnerships, especially, rely heavily on familiarity and communication. Liverpool have been unable to maintain a stable centre-back pairing, and injuries to full-backs have further weakened defensive transitions. When changes occur too frequently, structural discipline breaks down, and the team becomes vulnerable to counterattacks, set pieces and late-game lapses.

Injuries also affect rhythm in possession. A team that was once known for its fluid transitions and controlled aggression has instead looked fragmented and predictable at times because key creators and ball-progressors have been unavailable.

Tactical Identity in Transition

Since the departure of Jurgen Klopp, Liverpool have been adjusting to a new tactical philosophy. Replacing a long-established system built on heavy pressing and vertical attacking with a more controlled, possession-oriented approach is a major long-term shift.

The current squad is filled with players bought for a modern, technical, more structured system. But tactical evolution takes time, and recent performances show a team caught between two identities.

The pressing intensity that once defined Liverpool is not always present. The control and positional discipline that the new regime aims for has not fully taken shape either. As a result, the team gets stretched too easily, leaving gaps in midfield and exposing the defence.

This “in-between” phase is one of the biggest reasons why Liverpool look unstable despite major investment.

Defensive Fragility and Individual Errors

Another recurring issue is Liverpool’s defensive vulnerability. Even in matches where they dominate possession, they concede cheap goals through lapses in concentration, poor marking or failed clearances.

Many of these errors are individual, but they stem from systemic problems. When a team’s defensive shape is uncertain, players often make rushed decisions or find themselves covering for teammates out of position. That leads to confusion and split-second mistakes.

Opponents have found it too easy to target Liverpool’s defensive line, especially during quick transitions. Teams no longer fear Liverpool’s press the way they once did, and that shift in perception has invited opponents to be braver and more aggressive.

Mental and Psychological Pressure

Spending over £400 million creates enormous expectations. Supporters, pundits and even players themselves expect immediate improvements. When early results fail to meet those expectations, confidence drops.

A team under pressure plays differently. Passes become safer. Risks become rarer. Players hesitate rather than trust instinct. Liverpool have shown signs of this psychological burden in key moments of matches — conceding late goals, struggling to take control when leading, and looking anxious after conceding first.

Pressure is not a tactical issue, but it affects tactical execution. Liverpool must regain confidence to express themselves with the conviction expected of a top-level side.

What Needs to Change

Despite the disappointing start, Liverpool’s issues are not irreversible. Several steps can push the club back towards stability:

1. Establish a consistent defensive line.

Regular partnerships build understanding. Liverpool need to settle on a preferred back four whenever injuries allow.

2. Give new signings time to adapt.

The talent is there. Forcing them into immediate leadership roles may hinder natural development.

3. Improve defensive organisation, especially on transitions and set pieces.

Liverpool concede too many goals from preventable situations. Focused training here would bring immediate improvements.

4. Reduce tactical over-adjustments.

Stability in roles and structure will help players regain clarity.

5. Rebuild confidence and mentality.

The foundations of Liverpool’s resurgence in the past were built on belief and intensity. That mindset needs to return.

Conclusion

Liverpool’s struggles are the product of multiple overlapping factors: squad turnover, injuries, tactical evolution, defensive uncertainty and psychological pressure. Money can buy talent, but it cannot buy cohesion, chemistry or identity. Those must be built over time.

The club’s investment shows ambition, but the performances reveal a team still learning how to function as a unit. If Liverpool stabilise defensively, recover key players and fully internalise the new tactical approach, the quality of the squad suggests improvement is only a matter of time.

This analysis is brought to you by Football Matters TV in partnership with 1win. Get access to expert predictions, bonuses, and promotions—use promo code Footballmatters22 and make every match unforgettable!”